Avoiding Difficult Conversations? Easy Steps to Build Confidence & Improve Impact

Katrina Hechanova
13 hours ago
3 min read

In my early years as an HR Advisor, I hadn’t yet experienced many difficult conversations. I had never conducted a redundancy, nor had I been in the position of terminating someone’s employment. I was still learning, still observing, and often feeling the weight of responsibility that comes with guiding others through challenging moments.

I reported to an experienced HR Manager at the time, and I’ll never forget watching her prepare for a performance management discussion. She had handled dozens of these conversations before, but she never walked into one casually. She sat with her notebook, carefully mapping out the purpose of the meeting, drafting a few key questions, and outlining the steps she needed to follow to ensure nothing critical was missed.

What struck me was her discipline. She wasn’t over-rehearsing; she was preparing with intention, focus, and clarity of mind. The outcome was exactly what you’d hope for—clear, concise, and thoughtful communication that delivered the necessary message while preserving dignity and respect. It was a lesson I carried forward: preparation is what separates a constructive conversation from one that leaves scars.

Years later, while training a group of leaders on navigating tough conversations, one participant’s reflection reinforced this truth. He admitted that the conversations he had prepared for—the ones he entered with purpose, clarity, and an open mind—almost always went better than those he approached reactively. The contrast was undeniable.

Now, I know preparation takes time. And in today’s fast-paced, reactive workplaces, that time can feel like a luxury. But I’d ask you to pause and consider this: how much extra time and effort does it take to repair a conversation that has gone off the rails? Think about the impact on the individual’s mindset, engagement, and trust in you as their leader. Think about the ripple effects on your relationship and on team culture. Isn’t a few minutes of preparation worth avoiding that damage—and achieving a far better outcome?

Why Preparation Matters

Being prepared ensures you walk into the room with clarity, confidence, and purpose rather than emotion or reaction. Preparation allows you to:

Ground the discussion in facts rather than assumptions.
Anticipate concerns or defensiveness and plan for how you’ll respond.
Frame the dialogue in a way that builds trust, even in moments of tension.
Stay structured and focused on outcomes, not distractions.
Manage your own emotions so you remain steady and professional.

As Eleanor Roosevelt once said: “To handle yourself, use your head; to handle others, use your heart.” Preparation helps you do both.

And the data backs it up:

Avoiding or mishandling tough conversations costs organisations an average of $7,500 and seven workdays per conversation in lost time and productivity (HBR, 2022).
69% of managers feel uncomfortable giving feedback, especially when unprepared (HBR, 2017).
Leaders who prepare and use a structured approach to conflict improve team performance by 27% and decision-making quality by 29% (Center for Creative Leadership, 2018).
Preparedness and empathy together increase employee engagement by 40% (Gartner, 2021).

The evidence is clear: preparation isn’t optional—it’s essential.

The Cost of Skipping Preparation

When leaders avoid preparation, conversations often become reactive, unstructured, and far less effective. The risks include:

Miscommunication or leaving issues unresolved.
Damaged credibility and weakened leadership presence.
Wasted time, energy, and morale.
Heightened stress or defensiveness on both sides.
Erosion of trust and strain in the relationship.

In short, skipping preparation might feel like saving time in the moment, but it almost always costs you more in the long run.

A Framework for Leaders

If you’re about to step into a difficult conversation, ask yourself:

Am I clear on the message? What do I need to communicate without ambiguity?
Have I gathered the facts? Have I considered other perspectives or factors?
Have I checked my own emotions, assumptions, and biases? Am I grounded enough to lead calmly?
What will keep me present and focused? Do I have notes or a framework to guide me?
How do I want the person to feel after this conversation? Supported? Respected? Clear?
What action or change do I want to see as a result?

These questions don’t just prepare you logistically; they prepare you emotionally. They help you enter the conversation with purpose, clarity, and empathy—qualities that elevate not only the dialogue but also your leadership presence.

The Bottom Line

Difficult conversations are never easy. But they don’t have to be destructive. With preparation, they can be opportunities to build trust, clarify expectations, and strengthen relationships.

The leaders who prepare with intention demonstrate not only professionalism but also care. They show that the conversation matters, that the person matters, and that the outcome matters.

So next time you face a tough conversation, take a few extra minutes to prepare. Your future self—and your team—will thank you.

Why Preparation Matters

Being prepared ensures you walk into the room with clarity, confidence, and purpose rather than emotion or reaction. Preparation allows you to:

Ground the discussion in facts rather than assumptions.

Anticipate concerns or defensiveness and plan for how you’ll respond.

Frame the dialogue in a way that builds trust, even in moments of tension.

Stay structured and focused on outcomes, not distractions.

Manage your own emotions so you remain steady and professional.

As Eleanor Roosevelt once said: “To handle yourself, use your head; to handle others, use your heart.” Preparation helps you do both.

And the data backs it up:

Avoiding or mishandling tough conversations costs organisations an average of $7,500 and seven workdays per conversation in lost time and productivity (HBR, 2022).

69% of managers feel uncomfortable giving feedback, especially when unprepared (HBR, 2017).

Leaders who prepare and use a structured approach to conflict improve team performance by 27% and decision-making quality by 29% (Center for Creative Leadership, 2018).

Preparedness and empathy together increase employee engagement by 40% (Gartner, 2021).

The evidence is clear: preparation isn’t optional—it’s essential.

The Cost of Skipping Preparation

When leaders avoid preparation, conversations often become reactive, unstructured, and far less effective. The risks include:

Miscommunication or leaving issues unresolved.

Damaged credibility and weakened leadership presence.

Wasted time, energy, and morale.

Heightened stress or defensiveness on both sides.

Erosion of trust and strain in the relationship.

In short, skipping preparation might feel like saving time in the moment, but it almost always costs you more in the long run.

A Framework for Leaders

If you’re about to step into a difficult conversation, ask yourself:

Am I clear on the message? What do I need to communicate without ambiguity?

Have I gathered the facts? Have I considered other perspectives or factors?

Have I checked my own emotions, assumptions, and biases? Am I grounded enough to lead calmly?

What will keep me present and focused? Do I have notes or a framework to guide me?

How do I want the person to feel after this conversation? Supported? Respected? Clear?

What action or change do I want to see as a result?

These questions don’t just prepare you logistically; they prepare you emotionally. They help you enter the conversation with purpose, clarity, and empathy—qualities that elevate not only the dialogue but also your leadership presence.

The Bottom Line

Difficult conversations are never easy. But they don’t have to be destructive. With preparation, they can be opportunities to build trust, clarify expectations, and strengthen relationships.

The leaders who prepare with intention demonstrate not only professionalism but also care. They show that the conversation matters, that the person matters, and that the outcome matters.

So next time you face a tough conversation, take a few extra minutes to prepare. Your future self—and your team—will thank you.

Comments